A Case Study in Digital Marketing Success: From Hesitant Start to Explosive Growth

Hey everyone, Austin Dandridge here. No podcast this week, but figured I’d share a little story and insights of a client that seems to be working.

The power of personal connections in business is truly remarkable. In May 2023, we struck up a conversation with a potential client at The Southern C Summit in Sea Island. Carter and I were there as speakers, sharing our insights on how digital advertising and email marketing drive business growth. Little did we know that a casual lunch would lead to a transformative partnership.

Initial Hesitations and Strategic Recommendations

Our new client was hesitant about paid marketing, a sentiment we often encounter. She had built a successful niche business during COVID, and had bucked the trend of post-pandemic decline. Her influencer background had given her a strong start, but she felt her growth had plateaued. Despite her reservations, especially about Meta ads, she was open to exploring new avenues for growth.

We recommended starting with Google ads, focusing on Performance Max campaigns to showcase her products in the Google shopping feed. We also saw untapped potential in her Klaviyo account and suggested a content strategy overhaul.

The Client's Perspective:

• Cost-conscious but aware of plateaued growth

• Hesitant about paid marketing, especially Meta ads

• Operating in a niche market with post-COVID growth

Our Recommendations:

1. Implement Google Ads, focusing on Performance Max campaigns

2. Revamp Klaviyo email marketing strategy

3. Optimize email flows, particularly welcome series and abandoned cart emails

Launching the Strategy: A Phased Approach

Launching a new strategy is always exciting. In May, we kicked off with a modest Google ads budget and revamped her email marketing. The results were immediate and impressive. Her Google ads performance exceeded expectations, not just in branded search but in new customer acquisition. The redesigned emails, with tighter content and more direct calls to action, started outperforming her previous campaigns.

As we saw success, we slowly scaled up. By late summer, our client was ready to dip her toes into Meta ads, something she had initially resisted. We started small, leveraging her strong brand presence and high site conversion rate. Our approach was to create 'in-platform' content that felt natural rather than overly promotional.

Phase 1: Google Ads and Email Marketing (May 2023)

• Initiated Google Ads with a conservative test budget

• Redesigned email flows and content strategy

Phase 2: Scaling and Expansion (Summer 2023)

• Gradually increased Google Ads budget

• Introduced Meta ads with a small initial investment

Results and Growth

The growth was explosive. By year-end, her business had grown 217% compared to the previous year. And we didn't stop there. Year-to-date, we've pushed that growth to 272%. It's not just about throwing money at ads; it's about smart scaling, continuous optimization, and a holistic approach to marketing.

Year-End 2023:

• 217% growth compared to 2022

Year-to-Date 2024 Performance:

• 272% growth through increased marketing spend

Key Success Factors:

• Healthy content pipeline

• Smart product releases

• Effective pricing strategy

• Balanced focus on new customer acquisition and remarketing

The Cobble Hill Advantage: Beyond Platform Expertise

At Cobble Hill, we pride ourselves on going beyond platform expertise. We don’t just train the team in ad platforms; they understand accounting principles and the nuances of profitable growth. They also understand how to talk to clients and other team members like humans - imagine that, real human connection! Anyways, through placing an emphasis on smart and strategic growth, we've kept this brand’s marketing efficiency ratio at a healthy 8%, leaving room for further growth while maintaining profitability.

I like to make a point of using high quality ingredients to formulate the ‘recipe’ for digital marketing. A strong brand foundation, quality products, smart merchandising, and a balanced marketing approach across multiple channels all play crucial roles. We've learned that ads work best when they amplify existing strengths rather than trying to compensate for weaknesses.

Lessons Learned: The Recipe for Successful Digital Marketing

In the end, digital marketing isn't a silver bullet; it's part of a larger ecosystem. It works in tandem with product quality, customer service, and overall business strategy. For bootstrapped businesses, venturing into paid advertising can seem daunting, but it doesn't have to be unprofitable. The key is understanding that ads are just one piece of the puzzle in building a successful brand.

This client reminds me why I love what we do. It's not just about driving numbers; it's about partnering with passionate entrepreneurs, understanding their vision, and helping them achieve growth they never thought possible

Essential Ingredients For Profitability:

1. Strong brand foundation

2. Quality product in a growing market

3. Smart business decisions in merchandising and product strategy

4. Balanced marketing approach across multiple channels

5. Understanding of profitability thresholds

If you’re new, here’s how you can follow along with my weekly podcast:

→ Weekly episode on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple. Every Wednesday.

→ Short-form content on LinkedIn, Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok.